Treatment of Enemy Aliens in Queensland 1914-1920

This blog post is part of a series of essays commissioned by Queensland State Archives and written by historian Dr Murray Johnson.

Before the outbreak of the First World War in August 1914, German migrants were held in high esteem for their industriousness and agricultural skills. Successive Queensland governments actively encouraged German immigrants, who came to dominate rural communities in the Logan River district, Lockyer Valley, Darling Downs, Binjour Plateau in the Burnett, and centres in the far north. With the declaration of war, however, the strength of that admiration was soon to be tested, and as records at Queensland State Archives reveal, it was often found wanting.

Letter from the Senior Inspector of Police, Brisbane, to the Commissioner of Police, Brisbane, enclosing a weekly return of German and Austrian reservists in the District, September 1914
Letter from the Senior Inspector of Police, Brisbane, to the Commissioner of Police, Brisbane, enclosing a weekly return of German and Austrian reservists in the District, September 1914

The British Empire and its allies – including Australia – were faced by four major combatants:Germany, the Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman (Turkish) Empires and Bulgaria, which together formed the Central Powers. While there were relatively few Turks, Bulgarians and Austro-Hungarians residing in Queensland, the same cannot be said for the Germans and their descendants, who constituted a major segment of the population. As such they were the most visible ‘enemy aliens’.

Despite initial calls for restraint, the release in 1915 of the Bryce Report on alleged German atrocities, the sinking of the liner Lusitania by a German U-boat and the growing casualty lists from Gallipoli, all contributed to hardening attitudes against Germans and other former residents of the Central Power countries.As a precautionary measure suspicious enemy alien military reservists were incarcerated in Enoggera Internment Camp from September 1914, while non-reservists were registered and released on parole.The process of internment was selectively widened to embrace Lutheran pastors and other influential leaders of the German community. The steadily growing number of internees ultimately led to the closure of Enoggera in April 1916 and the transfer of 325 enemy aliens south to Holdsworthy on the outskirts of Sydney.They would be joined there by others as a curious social phenomenon took hold on the Queensland home front.

With hostilities on the far side of the world, propaganda and a determination to contribute to the Allied cause resulted in the manufacture of war within Australia itself. Towns and street names of Germanic origin were altered to make them more ‘British’, while many people of direct British descent became ultra-loyalists, seeking out the ‘enemy’ wherever they could be found. Their activities were reinforced from February 1916 by Commonwealth legislation which classified even the Australian-born as ‘aliens’ if they had fathers or grandfathers born in a hostile country. Nor did naturalisation necessarily provide any protection as it was not recognised beyond Australian shores and came to mean little within.

As Jurgen Iwers of Mackay found, applying for naturalisation was itself fraught with danger. Iwers was provided with a good character reference by local police only to become the object of suspicion when a horse was shot dead near his property. A subsequent police raid uncovered prohibited firearms and ammunition, with the Commissioner of Police concluding that Iwers was ‘a dangerous man’ and recommending his internment.

Others were watched closely by their ‘British’ neighbours who sought any evidence of disloyalty. Even the famed ‘Beachcomber’ of Dunk Island, Edmund Banfield, was not immune from the prevailing war psychosis. In December 1915 Banfield informed the Under Secretary for Home Affairs that a German named Henschel was preparing to purchase 300 acres of land on adjacent Clump Point, the frontage offering commanding views of the coast. Although conceding that Henschel appeared to be ‘a decent sort’, Banfield reminded William Gall of the ‘perfidy of the race and its duplicity’, suggesting that the sale should be blocked. It was, and Henschel was interned.

In the Boonah district of south-east Queensland police investigated claims that German farmers were stockpiling gold and silver to aid their homeland, an allegation soon found to be patently false. The mere presence of enemy aliens was also held to be an important factor in falling enlistment rates, and loyalist bodies such as the Kedron Recruiting Committee in Brisbane argued that ‘persons of enemy origin’ should ‘pay a special War Tax’. Under the provisions of the War Precautions Act authorities seized company shares held by enemy aliens, including those of 85-year-old C Reese of Fortitude Valley, who had been resident in Australia since 1852.

Idle chat put many at risk. At the Leyburn Cheese Factory Australian-born W G Greisheimen innocently remarked to a fellow milk supplier in December 1914 that with hostilities underway ‘I am afraid England will have a rough time of it’. His comments were reported to military authorities, who ordered local police to investigate. Constable John Reed found no evidence of ‘disloyalty’.

As the archival records nevertheless show, there were occasions when police and the government itself sided with enemy aliens against vindictive loyalists. Demands to purge the Queensland public service of all enemy aliens were unsuccessful, largely owing to their sheer number of the people involved. In January 1916, 65 ‘Germans’ were serving police officers, while another 192 were employed on the railways. No distinction was made, however, between the naturalised, non-naturalised or Australian-born.

Owing to their homelands being under the control of belligerent nations, Syrians and Poles were among other ethnic groups caught up in the home front conflict. Their numbers, however, were relatively insignificant. Bulgarians and Turks were similarly few in number: in November 1915 authorities identified just 14 Bulgarians residing in Queensland. Yet, such was the prevailing fear that Bulgarians and Turks were arrested and interned, later being transferred from Enoggera to Holdsworthy in April 1916.

After the war many of the internees were deported to their country of origin, including the most prominent internee of all – Eugen Hirschfeld, the honorary German consul to Queensland. A gifted medical man, Hirschfeld moved in society’s highest circles and on the eve of the First World War he was elevated to the Legislative Council, a position from which he quickly resigned. Unfortunately, Hirschfeld was an ardent advocate for the maintenance of German language and culture, contributing in no small measure to his persecution.

Very few women and children were interned, as authorities found it cheaper to pay the wives of internees 10 shillings per week, with an additional 2/6d per week for each child under 14 years of age. They hovered around the poverty line.

Until 1917 it was possible to escape increasing persecution by fleeing to the United States of America, the intended destination for the most bizarre deportation of all. The origins of Paul Freeman are obscure: at different times he claimed to be either American or Canadian. His guttural accent suggested that he was German. Freeman was also a member of the proscribed radical labour organisation, Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), foreign-born members of which had already experienced incarceration and deportation. In January 1919. Freeman was arrested at his lonely prospecting camp near Cloncurry and taken under armed guard to Sydney, from where he was deported to the United States. The Americans refused entry and Freeman was sent back to Sydney. Commonwealth authorities tried again – with the same result: Freeman was finally deported to Rotterdam in the Netherlands.

Records in Queensland State Archives, such as those illustrating Freeman’s remarkable odyssey, provide valuable insights on the 1914-1920 Queensland home front conflict that divided society.

About Queensland State Archives

For more information about Queensland State Archives visit www.archives.qld.gov.au

4 Responses

  1. my Uncle was one of those incarcerated by the Government… he was just a baby when his parents came to Australia and when he went to enlist to fight for Australia he was instead sent to prison…generations to come of our family will never forget that

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s